Judge Rejects Legal Request to Block Tree Cutting for Purple Line

Crews began clearing trees along light-rail route in Silver Spring Monday


Published:

A Purple Line sign on Connecticut Avenue posted near where a station will be

Andrew Metcalf

Tree cutting on the Purple Line could begin this week, as scheduled, after a federal judge on Friday rejected a request from the light-rail line’s opponents to halt tree cutting on the Georgetown Branch Trail.

U.S. District Court Judge Richard Leon in Washington, D.C., found that the plaintiffs—two Town of Chevy Chase residents and the trail advocacy group Friends of the Capital Crescent Trail—failed to meet the strict requirements needed for a temporary injunction.

Tree clearing will begin near Long Branch in Silver Spring Monday and clearing of small trees and undergrowth along the trail will start this week, said Chris Doherty, a spokesman for Purple Line Transit Partners, the state contractor building the project.

Leon wrote in his ruling that the plaintiffs, who were contesting whether the $900 million federal grant agreement was approved properly, failed to assert how blocking the grant would prevent the state from moving forward with construction using its own funds.

Leon said he could rule the grant agreement unlawful and set it aside, but that wouldn’t stop the state from moving forward with tree cutting.

“As a threshold matter, plaintiffs’ claims are plagued by a common problem: There is a mismatch between their legal claims and the injunctive relief they seek,” Leon wrote.

Leon also found the significant overlaps between this case and the plaintiffs’ previous case, which is now in the U.S. Court of Appeals in D.C., create jurisdictional issues about his ability to rule on it. The Purple Line opponents argued they couldn’t contest the grant agreement until it was signed and therefore this case rested on different grounds than their previous one, now being weighed by the higher court, that focuses on environmental concerns.

Leon disagreed.

“In my judgment, the overlap between this case and the case on appeal is so great that it cautions against granting the requested injunction,” Leon wrote.

He noted that lower courts typically must give deference to higher courts considering a similar case. He wrote that the appeals court already has granted a stay on his previous decision in the other case to vacate the project’s federal approval.

Leon previously called for a new environmental study to determine whether Metro’s ridership decline and safety issues would impact Purple Line ridership.

The appeals court’s stay has allowed Maryland to move forward with construction on the 16.2-mile light-rail line between Bethesda and New Carrollton while the court considers Leon’s other ruling calling for a study. The court is scheduled to hold oral arguments in that case Nov. 1.

In his ruling Friday, Leon wrote that the opponents’ arguments about the state failing to properly fund the existing transportation network before moving forward with the Purple Line “face tough sledding.” He wrote that plaintiffs failed to show that they were injured by Metro’s ridership decline, that their injuries were caused by the federal grant approved for the Purple Line project and that blocking the grant would address those injuries.

However, he didn’t toss the new case completely. Leon wrote at the end of his five-page ruling, “I may ultimately determine that plaintiffs’ case is meritorious as it proceeds through litigation and as additional evidence is put before the court.”

Back to Bethesda Beat

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Archive »Related Articles

Small Bites: Pines of Rome Opens in New Location, Reports Uptick in Customers

Plus: Urban Butcher unveils “meat mountain” for two; Bibibop named “hottest new concept;” brunch at Addie’s

MS-13 Members Stabbed Man More Than 80 Times in Silver Spring Park, Prosecutor Says

One suspect charged with murder was victim’s best friend, mother told police

Federal Judges Side with Rockville Officials in Case Over Thwarted Proposal for Self-Storage Facility

Suit faulted city for barring self-storage sites near public schools

Two Killed in Potomac Crash

Audi S4 left roadway and struck a tree; driver and passenger killed
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit Module
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Sponsored Content

Wireless Telecommunication Community Meeting

Join Montgomery County on Monday, October 23, in Rockville to discuss proposed zoning changes to address deployment of microtowers and small cell antennas.

Interested in Learning More About the Democratic Candidates for County Executive?

Join The Greater Bethesda Chamber of Commerce and Bethesda Beat as we host a debate featuring the Democratic Candidates for County Executive on November 15. Click to get your free tickets.
Edit ModuleShow Tags

More »

New Construction

Potomac, $1,999,999

Remodeled Colonial

Potomac, $1,075,000

Classic Chevy Chase Colonial

Chevy Chase, $1,319,000

Stunning Updated Tudor

Bethesda, $1,529,000

Transformed Colonial

North Bethesda, $1,295,000
Edit Module

Profiles

Your Guides to Leading
Local Professionals

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit Module

Edit Module