County Council Votes Against Reducing Energy Tax

In most contentious budget issue so far, council makes 5-4 decision


Published:

Via Montgomery County Council

The Montgomery County Council today narrowly voted against a 10-percent cut to the county’s energy tax despite a late push by many in the business community.

Council member Nancy Floreen had proposed a 10-percent cut that would’ve meant about $11.5 million less in revenue next fiscal year.

It would have followed similar cuts in the last three budgets to the roughly 85-percent increase pushed for by County Executive Ike Leggett and approved by the council in 2010.

Leggett proposed doubling the energy tax during the county’s fiscal crisis and bringing in an extra $133 million in revenue, with the promise of letting the increase sunset after two years.

But Leggett reconsidered the idea of letting the increase sunset, leading representatives from chamber of commerce groups and the building industry to lobby council members to make the change to Leggett’s budget.

Today’s council debate was likely the most contentious the nine-member body has had during this budget cycle.

Council President George Leventhal initially said the vote on the matter would be delayed until tomorrow, citing the fact that one member hadn’t decided and the council shouldn’t vote without a clear majority.

Council member Roger Berliner said the delay would allow the council to consider dipping further into the county’s reserves, a proposition he said would allow more budget flexibility.

That rankled council members who opposed reducing the tax, some of who said they would’ve proposed funding for other programs if they knew there might be more money available.

“If you guys have another $10 million you think you can go to the reserves for, I’ll take that money to go to class sizes,” said council member Marc Elrich, part of the Education Committee.

Berliner said he would’ve been open to more education spending if the Education Committee had pushed it forward.

“This is not about school capacity. The school system could decrease class size today,” Floreen said. “They just chose to spend their money in other places.”

Council member Hans Riemer then moved to overrule Leventhal’s decision to delay the vote. Council member Tom Hucker, the member who apparently was on the fence, advised Leventhal he was ready to vote.

The result, after a failed amendment by Berliner to reduce the energy tax by 5 percent, was a 5-4 vote against any reduction.

Council member Nancy Navarro, Riemer, Elrich and Hucker joined council member Craig Rice in voting against the tax cut.

Leventhal, Berliner, Floreen and council member Sidney Katz voted for it.

Nine business organizations, including the Montgomery County Chamber of Commerce and the Greater Bethesda-Chevy Chase Chamber of Commerce, wrote to the council that the tax unfairly forces businesses with small profit margins to pay 20 times more than non-commercial customers.

Back to Bethesda Beat

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Archive »Related Articles

Montgomery County Executive Candidates Show a Lighter Side During Debate

They answered questions about their ideal barbecue and what they’d do with free time on a Saturday afternoon

Differences Emerge in Four-Way Montgomery County Executive Candidate Debate

Frick said council members running for higher office have failed to solve county’s challenges

Trone Gives His Campaign $749K As He Starts Congressional Bid, Election Reports Show

Miller, relying on donations from fellow Indian-Americans, has $525K in bank in District 6 race

John Delaney Gets Financial Boost From Close to Home in Presidential Bid

One-third of early donors live in Bethesda, Chevy Chase and surrounding area, report shows
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit Module
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Sponsored Content

Wireless Telecommunication Community Meeting

Join Montgomery County on Monday, October 23, in Rockville to discuss proposed zoning changes to address deployment of microtowers and small cell antennas.
Edit ModuleShow Tags

More »

New Construction

Potomac, $1,999,999

Remodeled Colonial

Potomac, $1,075,000

Classic Chevy Chase Colonial

Chevy Chase, $1,319,000

Stunning Updated Tudor

Bethesda, $1,529,000

Transformed Colonial

North Bethesda, $1,295,000
Edit Module

Profiles

Your Guides to Leading
Local Professionals

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit Module

Edit Module